Some days ago I posted a question on the XPages development forum: Comparison of functionality between Extension Library (OpenNTF) and Upgrade Pack 1 (IBM).
I work in a hosted environment and having a change applied (continue to work with extension libraries from OpenNTF via Update site instead of Upgrade Packs) is a complicated issue. Therefor I have wrote down some use cases where new functionality in the Extension Library which are not available in the Upgrade Pack can bring value to the organisation.
To save time I only did the comparison on paper, which means I have only looked in the “readme” files distributed which each new release and compared them the “What’s new in Domino Designer 8.5.3 Upgrade Pack 1” online document. I admit this is probably not the best research but it helps you to get started.
Below you will find the comparison. Please respond in case I have missed something or understood incorrect. The use cases are too sensitive so I will leave them out of this document. Thank you in advance for your assistance!
|
Package name |
Extension Library |
Upgrade Pack 1 |
|
|
Release date |
2013 April |
2011 December |
|
|
Distributed by |
OpenNTF |
IBM |
|
|
Controls |
|
|
|
|
Area: Data Access |
|
|
Expose data access services. |
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
|
þ |
|
|
Area: Dojo Form |
|
|
Mimic components from the Dojo toolkit. |
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
Area: Dojo Layout |
|
|
Mimic components from the Dojo toolkit. |
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
Area: Extension Library |
|
|
Extend the capabilities of the Designer Core Controls. |
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
|
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
Area: iNotes |
|
|
Support certain views, lists, and stores. |
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
Area: Mobile |
|
|
Support mobile applications. |
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
Domino Access Services |
|
|
REST API that accesses databases on Domino servers. |
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
|
þ |
|
|
Updated templates |
|
|
Skeleton that contains design elements, but no documents. You |
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
þ |
þ |
|
|
- |
|
þ |
|
|
Social Business Toolkit |
|
|
Single source for developing integrations and leveraging IBM |
|
- |
|
þ |
|
|
Social Enabler |
|
|
Tools and controls for XPages to access information from other |
|
- |
|
þ |
|
|
- |
|
þ |
|
|
- |
|
þ |
|
|
- |
|
þ |
|
|
- |
|
þ |
|
|
- |
|
þ |
Storage of user credentials when an application needs to connect to third party servers. |










After an x number of years working in the same environment I have decided to look for a new challenge. Are you looking for a smart companion?
